选取2015-2019年洱源水化站FD-105K与FD-125测氡仪对比观测资料，采用一阶差分、F检验、t检验等方法进行对比分析，结果显示：FD-125测氡仪测值总体偏低，且测量精度较低，数据离散程度较高；2套观测数据变化趋势一致性不理想，相关性较低，未通过F检验和t检验。综合分析认为，FD-125测氡仪暂时不能替代FD-105K测氡仪进行观测，需要增加震例对2套仪器的映震效能进行验证。
The comparative observation data of FD-105K and FD-125 radon meters at Eryuan Hydrochemical Station from 2015 to 2019 were selected and analyzed by first-order difference, F-test, and t-test. The results show that the values of FD-125 are generally smaller than that of FD-105K radon meter, and the data stability is poorer and more discrete. The trend consistency of the two sets of observations was not ideal and their correlation was low, which did not pass F-test and t-test. Comprehensive analysis shows that FD-125 radon meter cannot replace FD-105K radon meter for observation at present, and earthquake cases are needed to check the reflecting efficiency of the two sets of instruments.
2020,41(2): 123-129 收稿日期：2019-10-21
DOI：10.3969/j.issn.1003-3246.2020.02.014
作者简介：段美芳(1994-),女,助理工程师,主要从事地震监测预报工作。E-mail:duanmeifangfang@163.com
*通讯作者：陆丽娜(1983-),女,博士,副教授,主要从事矿床学和地震地质教科研工作。E-mail:lulina@cidp.edu.cn
参考文献：
车用太,鱼金子,刘五洲. 水氡异常的水动力学机制[J]. 地震地质,1997,19(4):353-357.
胡玉良,程冬焱,李惠玲,等. 静乐井SWY-Ⅱ和LN-3A水位仪的对比分析[J]. 中国地震,2016,32(1):93-102.
李朝明,杨志坚,朱培耀,等.地震前兆监测中水氡测量方法浅析[J]. 地震地磁观测与研究,2013,34(Z1):155-161.
邱轶兵. 试验设计与数据处理[M]. 合肥:中国科学技术大学出版社,2008.
孙召华,夏修军,王恒业,等. 洛阳地震台模拟水氡仪FD-105K与SD-3B观测资料对比[J]. 地震地磁观测与研究,2017, 38(6):104-109.
唐采. 云南近期几次M ≥ 6.0级地震前水氡异常特征[J]. 四川地震,2004,(1):37-41.
杨芬,金明培,赵家本,等. 滇西实验场水汞同步性异常与中强地震的关系[J]. 国际地震动态,2009,(5):14-20.
张磊,高小其,包创,等. 呼图壁地下储气库构造气体地球化学特征[J]. 地震地质,2018,40(5):1059-1071.
张炜,王吉易,鄂秀满. 水文地球化学预报地震的原理与方法[M]. 北京:教育科学出版社,1988.
Crockett R G M, Gillmore G K, Phillips P S, et al. Radon anomalies preceding earthquakes which occurred in the UK, in summer and autumn 2002[J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2006, 364(1/2/3):138-148.
Erees F S, Aytas S, Sac M M, et al. Radon concentrations in thermal waters related to seismic events along faults in the Denizli Basin, Western Turkey[J]. Radiation Measurements, 2007, 42(1):80-86.
Ren H W, Liu Y W, Yang D Y. A preliminary study of post-seismic effects of radon following the MS 8.0 Wenchuan earthquake[J].Radiation Measurements, 2012, 47(1):82-88.
