与2008年5月12日汶川MS 8.0地震时记录到的大量压应变异常信号不同,2013年4月芦山MS 7.0地震前后姑咱地震台钻孔应变仪记录到的却是显著张应变异常,特别是临震前几日信号大幅度突升,而该时段恰巧台站大门前进行修路施工,这究竟是地球物理异常还是干扰,一直有很大争议。研究发现,这些异常信号在时间上具有高度的准同步性,即都发生在白天8:00—10:00或7:30—17:00之间,这正是工人的上班时间,而自然力产生的异常应具有随机性特征,不应有较强规律性;其次,临震前的异常振幅比芦山地震本身产生的振幅还大2倍,将其视为地球物理异常也有违常理。又结合腾冲地震台钻孔应变观测干扰实例进行分析,认为尚不能排除该张应变异常为施工干扰的可能性。
Different from a large number of abnormal signals of compressive strain recorded in the Wenchuan MS 8.0 earthquake in May 2008, significant tensional strain abnormal signals were recorded by a borehole strainmeter before and after the Lushan MS 7.0 strong earthquake in April 2013 at Guza seismic station. Especially, signal amplitude significantly enlarged a few days before the earthquake. The time period coincides with the road construction before the station gate. There has been a lot of controversy on whether it is a precursor or a disturbance. It is found that these abnormal signals have high quasi synchronization in time. They all appeared at 8:00—10:00 or 7:30—17:00 in the daytime. This is the time for the workers to work. And the abnormality produced by the natural force should have the characteristic of randomness, and it should not have such a strong regularity. Secondly, the abnormal amplitude before the earthquake is 2 times larger than that produced by the Lushan earthquake, which is counterintuitive to be regarded as a precursor. Based on the analysis of the interference examples of borehole strain observation at the Tengchong station, it is believed that the possibility of construction interference cannot be excluded.
2021,42(1): 98-104 收稿日期:2020-05-06
DOI:10.3969/j.issn.1003-3246.2021.01.014
基金项目:国家科技支撑计划项目(项目编号:2012BAK19B02-02)
作者简介:张凌空(1962—),男,高级工程师,主要从事钻孔应变等前兆方法的观测研究。E-mail:zhll1023@163.com
*通讯作者:牛安福(1964—),男,研究员,主要从事地形变预测地震的研究。E-mail:niuanfu01@sina.com
参考文献:
池顺良,刘琦,池毅,等. 2013年芦山MS 7.0地震的震前及临震应变异常[J].地震学报,2013,35(3): 296-303.
池顺良,池亮,池毅. 汶川地震和芦山地震的有助于预报的地震前兆[J].地球科学前沿,2017,7(2): 202-214.
刘琦,张晶. S变换在汶川地震前后应变变化分析中的应用[J]. 大地测量与地球动力学,2011,31(4): 6-9.
刘琦,张晶,池顺良,等. 2013年芦山MS 7.0地震前后姑咱台四分量钻孔应变时频特征分析[J].地震学报,2014,36(5):770-779.
邱泽华,周龙寿,池顺良.用超限率分析法研究汶川地震的前兆应变变化[J].大地测量与地球动力学,2009,29(4):1-4.
邱泽华,张宝红,池顺良,等. 汶川地震前姑咱台观测的异常应变变化[J].中国科学:地球科学,2010,40(8):1 031-1 039.
邱泽华,杨光,唐磊,等. 芦山M 7.0地震前姑咱台钻孔应变观测异常[J]. 大地测量与地球动力学,2015,35(1)158-161.
张凌空,牛安福. 姑咱台压应变异常信号与汶川和芦山等地震的关系研究[J].大地测量与地球动力学,2020,40(3):317-322.